Radhi Studi Go! terbitan 8TV Ciplak Tommy Lee Goes To College terbitan NBC?
Sebutkan apa sahaja… parody program? Program tv versi Malaysia? Francais Programme? Apa sahaja istilah yang diberikan, ia tetap satu jenis peniruan idea. Kalau American Idol dibawa ke Malaysia dan ditukarkan kepada Malaysian Idol, itu kita namakan francais programme? Ini satu lagi kes peniruan yang Budiey rasa dah menular secara meluas dalam show biz. Jika sebelum ini, KRU dengan lagu Aspalela ciplak lagu Indon, iaitu Abang Tukang Bakso dan Bintang Kejora, kini, 8TV, anak syarikat konglomerat media utama di Malaysia, 8TV menciplak idea sebuah rancangan realiti yang menerima sambutan hangat di US pada tahun 2005, iaitu Tommy Lee Goes To College.
Jika dilihat pengenalan dalam laman web 8TV hampir menyamai, dari segi penyampaian dan teknik penulisan untuk pengenalan bagi “Tommy Lee Goes To College” iaitu di website VH. Berikut adalah sedutan dari kedua-dua pengenalan bagi kedua-dua rancnagan tersebut.
Radhi Study Go! di 8TV
“Radhi, Study, GO!’ is about a Malaysian rock star ( Radhi, front man of OAG) getting away from his music life for awhile and do the things that he couldn’t do when he was younger, such as studying. Radhi, in his 30’s, who is known as a crazy headed guy, will now take the challenge to go back to college (SEGi) and choose whatever course he thinks he is suitable in. How is this possible? Radhi will be given a ‘Special Student’ status where he can switch from one course to another such as photography, video animation, automotive, nursing, and so much more. This reality TV show will show you how Radhi goes through this challenge and it is definitely not easy for a person who had stopped his studies during SPM, 15 years ago. Can he do it? Will he burst into tears? Will the lecturers go crazy? Or will he just not enter his classes? Find out more in ‘Radhi, Study, GO!’
Tommy Lee Goes To College di NBC
“The University of Nebraska at Lincoln (UNL) welcomes a motley new student to its campus - notorious rocker Tommy Lee. At the age of 19, Tommy formed Motley Crue, sending him on a meteoric rise to fame and fortune - who had time for college? Tommy was busy touring the world and living the fast life for two glorious decades. Cut to Tommy Lee today - twice divorced and the single father of two boys. Most men in their midlife crisis buy sports cars and date young women. Tommy wants something different, something money can’t buy - he wants academic redemption. Tommy packs up his bags, kisses his mom goodbye and heads off to UNL, but it won’t be class as usual when the new student is Tommy Lee!”
Adakah dengan kes terbaru ini, memang membuktikan pengiat seni kreatif industri seni di Malaysia sememangnya telah ketandusan idea untuk menghasilkan sesuatu yang baru. Atau mungkin mereka mengambil jalan mudah dengan meniru sahaja formula sedia ada yang terbukti telah berjaya dan mendapat hasil lumayan tanpa mengeluarkan bajet penyelidikan di Malaysia. Adakah slogan “Malaysia Boleh” akan menjadi slogan “Malaysia Boleh Ciplak” dan terkenal di seantero dunia. Fikir-fikirkan….
Technorati Tags: Radhi Studi Go!, Tommy Lee Goes To College, terbitan, NBC, hindraf, perhimpunan haram, anugerah skrin, pencalonan, network blog, glamour hollywood, tema anuerah skrin, unl, nebraska, lincoln, fashion faceoff, katie holmes instyle, hair style new, jennifer garner monday morning walk, chace crawford
Tags: 8TV, anugerah skrin, chace crawford, fashion faceoff, glamour hollywood, hair style new, hindraf, jennifer garner monday morning walk, katie holmes instyle, lincoln, NBC, nebraska, network blog, pencalonan, perhimpunan haram, Radhi Studi Go!, tema anuerah skrin, terbitan, Tommy Lee Goes To College, unlBaca artikel lain yang berkaitan:
hehehe…
December 11th, 2007 at 9:02 am
No hal. Malaysia Boleh! dan Malaysia Boleh Ciplak! Malaysia pun digelar top untuk pirated DVD/VCD. Kenapa tak mau masuk satu lagi senarai, ciplak idea (tanpa bayar royalti)….
December 11th, 2007 at 12:53 pm
ye betul.. tp ni versi malaysia.. rasa ciplak2 ni bukan perkara baru.. apa2.. malaysia mesti buat ape yg org luar dah buat
December 11th, 2007 at 1:13 pm
dah dengar lagu evergreen abang tukang bakso & lagu kanak2 bintang kejora tu.. tak same pun..
December 11th, 2007 at 5:35 pm
lagu die sikit punye best.
tp aku heran, kenape perlu buat mcm ni. sume tiru2 je program dari barat. kurang daya creative ke? aku perlukan duit je?
December 11th, 2007 at 5:37 pm
*silap, dorg gile sgt duit ke?
January 8th, 2008 at 8:21 am
Glad to know bukan aku sorang je fikir mcm tu. Read my Radhi Study Go post here: http://www.craplicious.com/2008/01/radhi-study-go-sucks-balls/
February 18th, 2008 at 10:10 pm
hmm.. pendapat saya la.. kalau bab ciplak idea tv shows ni berlambak dah.. banyak negara ada. bukan malaysia je. tak payah kepoh2. kalau tak suka takyah buang masa tgk
nk buat mcm mana.. itu semua hiburan.. tapi hiburan yang tak memberi pengajaran. klau ciplak tetapi memberi pengajaran takde la org nk marah ye tak? 